Present
Anthony Smith – HATF (Chair)
Mark Frost – HATF (Independent Technical Advisor)
Laura Keith – Head of Communications and Engagement (CISHA)
Peter Bradley – UK Coach Operators Association (UKCOA) (Managing Director)
Nigel Wicking – Airline Operators Committee (Chief Executive)
Keith McNally – Confederation of Passenger Transport (Operations Director)
Christian Wolmar – London Cycling Campaign (Trustee)
Alan Tilly – Hillingdon Council (Transport Planning and Development Team Manager)
Shamal Ratnayaka – Transport for London (Aviation Strategy Lead)
Jo Grew – Network Rail (Industry Programme Director (Heathrow & TVA))
Tim Neate – National Highways (Senior Planning Manager)
Wayne King – Unite the Union (Regional Secretary)
Puja Bedi – Representative from Local Community Forum (LCF)
Dan Philips – Senior Transport Planner (Arup)
Matthew Rhodes – Associate Director (Arup)
Sophie Chapman – HAL (Surface Access Director)
Tim Leech – HAL (Head of Strategy and Sponsorship, Surface Access)
Tim Wells – HAL (Sustainable Travel & Policy Lead)
Simi Kullar – HAL (Sustainable Travel Manager)
Sam Berry – HAL (External and Government Affairs Manager)
James Golding – HAL (Head of Cargo)
Wesley Lang – HAL (Senior Research and Insight Manager)
Apologies
Matthew Furniss – Surrey County Council
Liz Garlinge – Highways England(Strategic Projects Director)
Paul Millin – Heathrow Strategic Planning Group (HSPG) (Chair, Transport Subgroup)
Polyvios Polyviou – Business LDN (Programme Director, Transport)
Live Actions
Action 5:
Look at type of taxis arriving at airport, e.g. electric/fossil fuel split.
Update: HAL working through data privacy process to unlock access to automatic number plate recognition (ANPR) data.
Owner: TW, HAL
Date opened: 27/09/2023
Target completion date: Dec 2024
Action 13
Investigate path to achieving 3-hour public transport catchment
Update: Action opened on September board, and updates will be provided going forward.
Owner: HAL
Date opened: 17/09/2024
Target completion date: Ongoing
1. Welcome and Introductions
The Chair, Anthony Smith (AS), welcomed attendees to the fourth Board meeting of
2024.
Action Updates
5. Tim Wells (TW): currently in the process of accessing ANPR data, which will show split of EV and other vehicle types using Heathrow’s road network. Currently working through data privacy process.
12. Cargo update will be provided within meeting.
2. HAL Update
Sophie Chapman (SC) provided a Heathrow update:
- Passenger numbers continue to grow, with 8 million passengers in August, these numbers reflect the busy summer Heathrow had. On 18 August, Heathrow had its busiest ever day with 269,000 passengers
- Operations are running reasonably smoothly despite the busy summer, noting there were a few incidents including the global IT failure.
Mode share & Surface Access Targets
- Public transport mode share for August 2024 was 44.7% (target for 2024 was 44%) with a Moving Annual Average of 44.6%
- Peter Bradley (PB): the rail based modes always seem to perform well in terms
of passenger satisfaction when there is good reliability and less engineering
works, do you have data to support this? SC: next slide will show passenger
satisfaction data, but this evidence does support this - Colleague mode share: the colleague travel survey is currently live and will provide the latest mode share data for colleagues when finalised at the end of this year
- SC: We have already achieved the 2026 target of an increase of 25% of the population who can access the airport within a 1.5-hour journey time, mainly due to Elizabeth Line and investment in local bus. However the 3-hour catchment is still yet to be achieved – the 2026 target being 12%, with the 2023 figure being a 9% increase. Heathrow has less control over the 3-hour catchment due to distance from the airport and cuts to some regional services in recent years. Further investigation will be undertaken on the pathway to achieving this target and reported at future board.
Customer Satisfaction
- Customer satisfaction for all modes have gone up when compared to previous quarter, which could be due to improved performance in terms of reliability for rail especially
- AS: Surprised that Piccadilly line is so high, could the (relatively) low price be a reason why it scores well, as users do not expect such a high-quality service. The line does represent value for money when compared to Elizabeth Line and will improve further when new trains start being rolled out by TfL in 2025
- Nigel Wicking (NW): from the Airline’s perspective passengers aren’t complaining about Surface Access, the main issue is baggage. Last year people were turning up early, as they were worried about being on time, which impacted the airport flow and passenger satisfaction
- Wesley Lang (WL): passenger satisfaction scores have remained good over the summer, but we are always looking at making improvements based on passenger feedback.
Carbon and Sustainability Projects
- Colleague Car Parking Strategy is currently in its very early stages. More detail will be provided in 2025
- SC provided an update on the Sustainable Travel Zone (STZ) including improved frequency and operating hours for some services. More information on discounted colleague travel can be found here Commuting to Heathrow
- Pantograph charging to facilitate electric buses within the CTA is currently progressing, with terms being negotiated with TfL
- Travel wallet: the aim for this is to implement an app for all Team Heathrow colleagues, to provide a one stop shop for everything related to commuting including real time information, ticketing, car share and rewards.
Terminal Drop off Charge (TDOC)
- Passenger satisfaction for forecourt drop off remains high, as shown by Kiss and Fly remaining the highest rated out of all transport modes
- Due to car parking prices across the airport campus rising alongside RPI, the costs of short stay pick-up are now more than the TDOC, and this disparity is attracting more people to use the forecourt and impacting the forecourt flow. Landside Operations have reported safety and behavioural issues with forecourt usage
- We have also seen public transport mode share increase since the introduction of TDOC, which is caused by a combination of TDOC and the Elizabeth line. Further measures are required to exceed the target of 45% public transport mode share
- As a result, we plan to increase the existing £5 TDOC to £6. We are in the process of a consultation with airlines about this change through the annual pricing consultation for 2025. The price of TDOC will then be reviewed annually, as per any other parking product, but this should not be interpreted that we will decide to increase it every year.
- AS: looking at other UK airports, how does the new price compare? SC: we are
currently one of the lowest, and when increased to £6 Heathrow will still not
be the highest - WK: when first introduced, TDOC was explained as a temporary measure to support finances and was going to be removed post Covid. Is TDOC just a money making scheme? SC: TDOC was introduced primarily to encourage sustainable modes of travel to the airport and manage traffic flow on the forecourts Important to note that a free drop off option will continue to remain at Park and Ride (previously long stay) car parks to provide choice
- AS: will this increased cost encourage more people to park instead of just drop
off? SC: when we increased roll up (non-prebooked car parking) prices, we
saw shift to forecourt usage, which we do not want. TW: Car parking is
actually a preferred option from a sustainability perspective when compared
to Kiss & Fly and Taxi/PHV, because it contributes only two vehicle trips,
compared to four for those involving a drop off. - Tim Neate (TN): have you seen if TDOC has helped with public transport
uptake? TW: it is hard to measure, as we have had ULEZ, Elizabeth Line and
improved bus routes come through since TDOC was implemented. Tim Leach
(TL): A combination of push and pull factors are required to influence
behavioural change and achieve the shift to sustainable modes required so it
might be expected to have contributed in some way, but how much is difficult
to determine.
Eye Tracking Insights: Improving Passenger Wayfinding
WL presented findings on how passengers navigate terminals, with the aim to ensure
journeys are as smooth as possible. Key points:
A key takeaway is the need to have signage at key points along the passenger
journey to avoid bottlenecks and aid decision making
- Findings from eye tracking so far have helped to make and implement signage improvements across terminals, including the passenger journey to the train station
- 7 key takeaways provided within the slides, including height of signage, clarity on directions, de-cluttering and iconography. Roof mounted signage in particular seems especially effective
- AS: how did you choose the 100 passengers for this trial, and what will be your measure of success? WL: it was generally random sampling but trying to focus on people who were not regular travellers and had higher levels of unfamiliarity with the airport. The fact that the technology would not work with those who had a visual impairment was noted. The measure of success will be identifying current bottlenecks and the impact of new and improved signage. This should result in improved customer satisfaction scores covering wayfinding
- AS: pay more attention to sample population, especially those who are not frequent passengers. WL: we do pre-screen passengers, so do not ask very familiar passengers to take part, instead we want new and unfamiliar travellers
- NW: did you cover families and non-English speakers. WL: non-English speakers was not a requirement but we did target elderly couples and families. We could not focus on passengers requiring support, as they areusually with staff who take them through the terminal.
4. Cargo Update, Including Future Proposals
James Golding (JG) provided an update on cargo including Cargo Strategy and future proposals:
- The cargo strategy sits under the refreshed corporate strategy and has a particular focus on people and planet and value to customers.
- The underlying mission is to grow the cargo proposition to be fit for future, provide tools and techniques to meet needs of customers including airlines and colleagues
- 3 goals are set out within the strategy:
- grow volume and market share
- increase efficiency. Implement a digital booking system to increase efficiency of landside HGV movements
- be a better place to live and work. Minimise impact on neighbouring residential communities
- Truck call-forward parking facility will be provided to the south of Southern Perimeter Road, along Scylla Road. This will ensure any early arriving HGVs will park in a dedicated facility instead on local roads
- Mark Frost (MF) Strange not to see reducing carbon emissions noted as an objective? JG: The cargo strategy fits within a wider suite of policies including the airports Carbon strategy which commits to reducing emissions in the coming years. We are working with carbon team to track carbon emissions resulting from cargo
- MF: as part of the better place to live and work goal, are you looking at road safety and conflict between cyclists and lorries? JG: we currently do not have any levers currently to ensure lorries are complaint with latest safety innovations or schemes like Freight Operator Recognition Scheme (FORS), but will look into this further as the cargo project develops. Surface Access-led projects to introduce new active travel facilities on the airport’s road network will help ensure safe separation between HGVs and cyclists
- AS: Have you seen increase in electric cargo vehicles? JG: Most vehicles using Cargo Centre are diesel, there are a few trialling electric vehicles, but this is mainly airside
- Forecasting 1.5million tonnes of cargo going through Heathrow, including trans-Shipment. Trans-shipment that takes place wholly within the airport boundary does not have an impact on vehicle movements
- MF: Is there a trade-off between increasing passenger numbers and carrying freight JG: There is a balance increasing passenger numbers with increased cargo space. But increasing passenger numbers would mostly be achieved through having more bigger planes, so more seats for passengers but also cargo space in belly (so called “Up-gauging”). Managing slots changes by swapping short haul to long haul routes would also likely increase cargo quantum.
Cargo Centre Redevelopment
- Working with Segro, a major operator and landowner, to redevelop the Cargo
Centre to increase capacity and improve efficiency. The scheme is broken into
two projects, Cargo East and Cargo West - Timescales: Cargo East will be completed first, to create additional capacity,
with works starting at the end of 2026 and complete early 2029. Unable to
start sooner than end of 2026 due to runway resurfacing programme using
the existing site. Cargo West will be delivered over 2030, 2032 and 2034 – due
to it being a very constrained site and space require for existing use - This development will mean more employees so the project team are looking
at providing the necessary surface access to the area, including potential
improvements in bus provision and cycle facilities - AS: will there be more truck movements as a result of the redevelopment? JG:
There is a hope that new ways of working will deliver efficiencies, but full
transport modelling and assessments will take place in due course - Shamal Ratnayaka (SR): instead of buses coming in and going out as per the
existing bus setup, can we ensure buses stop along Southern Perimeter Road,
which will reduce journey time. JG: yes, this is on our radar and we will be
looking into options to improve efficiency of bus access - Christian Wolmar (CW): as part of cargo redevelopment, will road layouts be
changed, so new cycle routes will be impacted? JG: we are working with the
surface access team to ensure cycle routes are designed in a way not to be
impacted by proposals.
5. Network Rail Update
Jo Grew (JG) provided an update on recent disruption on the Great Western Mainline as a consequence of various failures in infrastructure, and longer term disruption as a result of planned development work at Old Oak Common to facilitate an interchange with the new HS2 service:
- At the end of 2023 there was poor performance along Western Route, so we launched a recovery plan (called Project Brunel). There are 3 parts of the project:
- To stabilise infrastructure,
- Improve interventions (current stage)
- Sustain phased (BAU). Likely to commence in 12-18 months
- There are two main areas of concern in terms of the causes of recent delays including a) points (where trains change track) and b) trespasses/ fatalities
- AS: Why do track closures mainly occur on Sunday, does your data support the case for this? JG: We have checked the data and Sunday remains our lowest revenue day, despite the recovery seeing increased leisure travel at the weekend
- We have set up a passenger handling plan to cover a number of All Line Block
(ALB) episodes, including a 5 day All Line Block during Christmas 2024 - SR: TfL are working with Network rail and Heathrow to ensure the Piccadilly
Line is running during this time and avoiding any conflicts in engineering works
due to the Piccadilly line’s own upgrade programme.
7. AOB
- MF: Southern Rail. Following the agreement at the last board meeting,
Anthony has sent a letter to Secretary of State to set out HATF position on the
proposed rail scheme, confirming the Forum’s support for Heathrow
Southern Rail’s (HSR) scheme. We are still waiting a response. SC: met with
Department for Transport (DfT), who were aware of letter and will draft up
response. A future meeting with Lord Hendy is proposed
Spelthorne have continued to review their position following a meeting of the
Business Investment and Growth Committee on Monday 16 September where
this item was discussed with presentations on both the HSR and the light rail
scheme. The work undertaken by HATF to explore both of these schemes that
the Forum was involved was also presented. As a consequence, the council no
longer have an in-principle position in favour of their light rail scheme, and will
set up a working group to consider their position on Southern Rail Access, to
report later in 2024. - Bus Service Improvement Plan (BSIP) update: Heathrow will reconvene BSIP
SIG to consider next steps, and a meeting is proposed in the coming weeks in
order to progress.
Next meeting: Monday 18th November, followed by HATF Wider Forum. Taking place
in-person at Hounslow House.
